Year round education a bad idea
October 30, 2017
One change that should not be made is the switching from the education system that most of the nation currently employs, which is a 10-month system, to a year-round education system. A growing number of districts are making this switch due to the concern for summer learning loss.
Switching to a year-round education system is not a good idea because it does nothing to combat summer learning loss, it does not provide sufficient down time and it takes away summer break which is an important component in having a healthy childhood.
Every society, nation and culture changes and adjusts itself to how the majority of the people living in that society operate. To change the way a culture functions is the hardest change to make due to the fact that it requires a large number of people to change how they operate during their daily lives.
According to Thoughtco, this year-round education system comes in many different forms. Most of the schools that employ this system operate on a single-track year-round school calendar, which can include a 45-15, 60-20 and 90-30 schedule. This means that you have 45 days of school (referred to as work period) followed by 15 days of break (referred to as rest period). All of those systems provide enough time for an average student to forget what they learned over the last work period, which entirely defeats the purpose of a year-round education system.
The calendar system that year-round education programs use not only make it pointless to switch to year-round education, they also complicate the lives of students, parents and families as a whole. During the summer break, many students use this down time to take up a summer job to buy their first car or for some, help support their families. Taking away the extended summer break would crush this crucial part of the average American teenager. For teachers with young children, it would be difficult to find a babysitter who can work for a certain amount of days, then go several days without any income. It is much easier to find a babysitter who can work the entire summer, which also offers a teenager a possible summer job.
The down time of summer is necessary in the healthy development of children. Some students spend their summer vacation outside by going to youth camps, working out or going to the pool. Some experts say these activities are crucial to remaining healthy. Dr. Susanne Preston, a mental health counseling instructor at South University Virginia Beach is one such expert.
“The fresh air and sunlight have the largest benefits,” Preston said in an article written by Jared Newman. “For example, with increased exposure to natural sunlight, incidents of seasonal affective disorder decrease. When individuals are exposed to natural sunlight, the vitamin D in their skin helps to elevate their moods. Research has shown that spending time in nature has been associated with decreased levels of mental illness, with the strongest links to reduced symptoms of depression and anxiety, in addition to increased self-esteem.”
According to the July 2010 edition of the Harvard Health Letter there are several positive results of going outside. Some of them are a rise in your levels of vitamin D, which may have many positive effects such as fighting diseases. The downtime during summer gives children the chance to lead a healthier lifestyle. Take away the summer break, you take that chance with it as they can’t really gain the same benefits from such activities while in a classroom.
All of the information previously stated, shows that not only is year-round education difficult to execute, but also pointless. It also complicates the lives of teenagers, parents, teachers and families as a whole. On top of that it still takes away downtime that is vital to the healthy development of children.
For these three reasons, year-round education should not be allowed under any form to be integrated into how our society and culture currently functions.
Liia Sarkisova • Jul 28, 2023 at 4:40 pm
This is really good information!
Liliana Duarte • Jul 24, 2023 at 5:06 pm
I can understand Micheal Simmons’s perspective as to how year-round education is not a good idea because of its newness and complexity, its potential to cause academic forgetfulness, and the importance of healthy adolescent development. However, I believe that year-round education would be highly beneficial, and may actually be the solution to these said educational issues; this meaning the weight of the issues addressed in this article over year-round education could actually be reduced by implementing year-round education. For instance, Simmons claims that a shift like this would be detrimental for students’ education because they would forget what they learned over their breaks. However, with the traditional schooling schedule, Summer break is almost 3 months long and causes students to have to spend extra time re-learning material in the following school year. An article from the New York Times takes a look into this case; Dr. Dominic Annacone, an administrator of the Sag Harbor School District, attested that year-round schooling would counteract this problem because they would have a more stable learning regimen. Another pro-year-rounder who is president of a research company, Alexa Smith, touches on concern for students who’s second language is English saying, ”Over a long summer vacation these students may tend to forget their English,” based on studies.
Secondly, the standard education schedule with a long summer break would not ensure healthier childhood development because this typical education schedule contributes to great amount of inconsistency. As someone in high school, my friends and I always find ourselves overwhelmed and exhausted throughout the last few months of nearly every school year since middle school. By the end, we are burnt out and more than ready for a break, only to have to re-adjust when the next school year comes around. With year-round schooling, students would learn consistency in life, which is vital for success. Having more frequent breaks would also help to dodge the burn out that the majority of students feel toward the end of a regular school schedule. On top of that, students would still get time off in the summer, just not as much because breaks would be more spread out to then again, avoid burn-out. Lastly, Simmons states that this would be a large and difficult change to make because it would take great amounts of people on board for a transition like this to even happen. Except, change isn’t always a bad thing and every big advance in the world started small. There will always be imperfection throughout every realistic system. Someone will always be unhappy no matter the conditions. What it really comes down to is what system is the least imperfect overall and which will most likely ensure the best outcome for society?
Hellen Trivour • Jun 5, 2023 at 7:19 am
year around shool is bad bcz it could end up being expensive
Mary • Apr 24, 2023 at 9:08 am
I am very glad I don’t have to do year round school.
Kelsey • Apr 3, 2023 at 1:48 pm
I really like this website! The reasons are great, and the sources are reliable!
Lydia • Mar 9, 2023 at 2:37 pm
Year round school IS a bad idea.It would take away family time and much needed breaks.Poor kids would be so tired.
Layla Anderson • Apr 26, 2022 at 11:30 am
I think that year around school should be banned because people want to do things out of school.
Ryan • Sep 5, 2020 at 11:00 pm
I never had the traditional school schedule until high school. Year round school really sucked as a kid. I felt like I never had any breaks. Most of my teachers assigned tests and homework for the day we got back so it really wasn’t a break at all. I felt overworked and stressed. Children should have fun! They have the rest of their lives to be stressed. Also, my sister was always on a different track than me. We had different “vacation” days and it really screwed with my parents. I don’t know how they didn’t go nuts.
Marian • May 15, 2018 at 8:33 am
Isn’t supposed to be, “Year Round Education Is a Bad Idea” instead of “Year Round Education a Bad Idea.”?
adviser • May 16, 2018 at 8:02 am
We use newspaper style standards for headline writing. Thanks for your message.